In its first seasons, three sides were fielded. A club history written in 1952 claims that in 1881/82 the Club played six more matches than any other side in the country, making a total of 50 matches of which they won 28, lost 12 and drew 10. By the 1887/8 season, the number of teams had increased to six and by the 1930s ten sides were fielded every Saturday playing between 20-30 matches each during the season.
The Club and its 1st XI saw mixed success over the years. In 1883, it reached the third rounds of the English and London Senior Cups. In 1884, the 1st XI reached the semi-final of the London Senior Cup. They played at Kennington Oval in front of a 1,000 strong crowd but were beaten by Old Foresters 6-0. They were regularly playing matches against a wide variety of teams. These included church teams, university and polytechnic teams, local teams as well as workplace teams such as the Metropolitan Police and the Civil Service. In the 1890/91 season Tottenham Hotspur, Queen’s Park Rangers and Royal Arsenal (now Arsenal) were among the 1st XI’s fixtures. In 1951, the 1st XI saw an exceptional season in which they lost only one match, scoring 95 goals in 30 matches.